The Hot Blog

I really hope The Devil Came on Horseback is on there...

not that it would have won but i'd have liked to see 'king of kong' make the cut....

this may turn out to be the only category in which one of the 'sand movies' stands a chance...

My initial sense is that Sicko will win the category, with No End In Sight being a sleeper alternative. Box-office, marketability, relevance to the time period, controversy, etc. will probably help solidify another Oscar for Michael Moore. Thoughts?

I would ordinarily agree with you, Scott, but I really think No End in Sight is such a better doc that anybody who actually watches both will be struck by that reality. I'm rooting for The Devil Came on Horseback, but I think No End in Sight is the most important "Iraq" film made and I think that the war is on a lot more people's minds right now than healthcare. But, I could be wrong.

I'd be surprised if In the Shadow of the Moon doesn't get in. It's not a hot button issue film, but it's pretty inspiring, and it's something that all the fogies in the Academy are going to love reliving.

Jimmy Carter by way of Jonathan Demme has got to get in, right?

I can't believe The Devil Came on Horseback didn't even make the shortlist. Granted, it's a tough year for documentaries, but that one was an important film on an important topic and done so well. I'm really broken up about this one. I can't believe Sicko and Body of War were put in ahead of it.

I'm disappointed at myself for missing so many of these, but at the same time if they're only going to show Lake of Fire for a week that doesn't leave much of a window of opportunity.

PS: I worked on one of the short-listed films, so that's nice.

I recently rented CRAZY LOVE and did NOT get what all the hype is about. Sure, it's a great story....but the story has been recounted endlessly in print and television. It's not like the filmmakers discovered a great story and made a doc about it. I also didn't think it was made particularly well nor was it made to look interesting. It looked like Doc Film 101 filmmaking.

That being said, I hope KING OF KONG sneaks in there!

In my opinion, having seen most of these, OPERATION HOMECOMING is the best one on this list. I'm shocked the academy found it. If you haven't seen it -- you should. It's a non-political, yet profoundly affecting, look at the war directly from the soldiers' point of view. Not medicine! Entertaining and totally unique (so few docs blaze new ground these days). check it out.

"Wiener Takes All" for 2008!

Did docs like Moon, Kong, Horseback, Paint, Plains and Darfur not meet the eligibility criteria of however many cities or whatever it is. Or what? Cause those are pretty high profile as documentaries go and to not be on there is very strange.

Shame about Steal a Pencil For Me :p

Jeff, congrats, are you allowed to say which one?

It can't have been an eligibility thing for Kong or Moon, it must have been the selection committee literally not choosing them, which is lame.

I was assistant editor on the one that's misspelled.

Glad to see "Lake of Fire" made the list: that's a pleasant surprise coming from those incredibly myopic folks at the Academy doc committee.
"Fire," "Sicko" and "No End in Sight" are the obvious doc class acts of the early finalists.
I'm guessing the Oscar will probably go to "No End."
And shockingly--considering the subject matter--it's probably the least 'controversial" and divisive of the bunch.
Too bad about "Devil Came on Horseback" not making the cut, though. I just watched it a few weeks back on DVD and thought it
was terrific.

I was lucky to see BODY OF WAR at AFI fest in LA. It was sold out but someone had an extra ticket and I popped in. I have seen NO END IN SIGHT and all the other Iraq docs. All good, all have a purpose. But BODY does something all If you don't know anyone affected by this war, the others don't: it makes the war personal. If you don't know someone directly affected by the war, you will after you watch the film. Some scenes are painful, and the hero is not always heroic, but the film will rattle your heart and soul and move even the most cynical viewer to tears. BODY is deceptively simple in its structure and brings you into the bedroom of a man who lost everything in the war, while his country did nothing. He watches his brother get shipped to Iraq, while he is denied basic care from the VA. So many great docs, but BODY deserves to win.

They've released the official list:

Autism: The Musical
Body of War
For the Bible Tells Me So
Lake of Fire
Nanking
No End in Sight
Operation Homecoming: Writing the Wartime Experience
Please Vote for Me
The Price of Sugar
A Promise to the Dead: The Exile Journey of Ariel Dorfman
The Rape of Europa
Sicko
Taxi to the Dark Side
War/Dance
White Light/Black Rain

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

URL:
Remember me? YesNo

Comments: