« No Wonder Keith Olberman Hates Her... She's The Competition! | Main | Mean Girls 2008 »

September 16, 2008

TIFF - Che' Goes 131x2

My first reaction to Steven Soderbergh’s Che’ was absolute shock at the idiocy and arrogance of it all… that is to say, the idiocy and the arrogance of the response from Cannes.

This is one reason why I hate seeing a movie “after the fact.” It is a real challenge to all critics – and any one of them that claims it is not is more self-delusional than most and should probably be more distrusted – to not react to the criticism of others, whether to embrace it or to reject it, when one sees a film that gets the kind on biting response that Che’ got in Cannes.

====================

It is ironic that The Wrestler got so much love at Toronto, given that Guerilla is so similar as a storyline, albeit set in quite different universes. The Wrestler tells the story of a man struggling to survive his past while wanting nothing so much as to wallow in it. Of course, in The Wrestler, Mickey Rourke’s character is writ small… tiny, really. Ernesto Guevara is as quiet as Rourke’s wrestler, but while Rourke’s character struggles with his tiny fame, Guevara holds many lives in his hand as a result of his… and still, struggles.

For people looking for a snap and slap testament to Che’s greatness or his hypocrisy or anything definitive, this will never quite work. It just isn’t a straight biopic. It has more in common with Malick’s The Thin Red Line and the second half of Kubick’s Full Metal Jacket than any more traditional war epics… there is a bit of Patton, in conceit though not remotely in character, as well. Soderbergh and his collaborators have taken the story of Che’ Guevara to define their ideas much the way Robert Bolt did for Lean, though this film creates intimacy like Bolt created epics (though Lean hired actors who brilliantly undercut the stuffiness of Bolt to make most of their films together a perfect balance). Che’ is Brando to most biopics’ Heston.

The rest...

Posted by dpoland at September 16, 2008 08:02 PM

Comments

Terrific review. Can't wait to see this now.

Posted by: PastePotPete [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 16, 2008 10:22 PM

"This is one reason why I hate seeing a movie 'after the fact.'” Now you understand why I hate limited-releasing in the 21st century. It's simply ridiculous. FUCK THE SLOW ROLL!

Posted by: IOIOIOI [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 16, 2008 11:42 PM

GEE, I can't wait till I wake up in the morning and find the requisite 21 posts from Nicol Douche complaining about the mere existence of this movie "Che" and how Hollywood is attacking his values and universities promote Marxism and blah blah blah blah blah blah...

To all of which, I ask, DO YOU REALLY CARE? I just want to see a GODDAMN GOOD MOVIE. Sorry if it's buying into the "liberal Hollywood brainwashing of America," Nicole, but when Steven Soderbergh and Benicio Del Toro make some grainy, gritty, ambitious epic about giant issues and provocative subject matter, EXCUUUUUUUSE ME for being just a LITTLE more excited than I am for "American Carol."

On Nicol's beloved conservative blogs and on conservative talk shows, "Che" is like the 900-pound gorilla of the the year, as if this movie about a revolutionary who's been dead FOR FORTY YEARS is going to singlehandedly bring down the American way of life. "Sorry, honey, we can't have our fiftieth fucking kid, and Christmas is canceled, because Soderbergh went and made a movie about the dude annoying college kids wear on their T-shirts."

I am going to be very clear about this for the people in the cheap seats, but MOVIES OWN and THE NEWS IS BORING, so if they make a movie about some real dude -- be it JFK, NIXON, ALI, PATCH FUCKING ADAMS -- I don't GIVE A DAMN about agendas or even adherence to the facts. I want a GOOD MOVIE.

There are MOVIE PEOPLE and there are POLITICAL PEOPLE. MOVIE PEOPLE see something like JFK and think, "THAT MOVIE FUCKING OWNS HOLY SHIT MASTERPIECE!" POLITICAL PEOPLE see JFK and start bitching about facts and distortion and agendas and liberal Hollywood, and it's BORING. Movies are more important to me. Fuck, Soderbergh and Stone could co-direct a BIOGRAPHY ABOUT ME, filled with lies, distortion, slander, representing me as my complete, total opposite, and all I'd care about is if the movie FUCKING OWNED.

I would think that anyone who TRULY LOVES FILM should be able to LEAVE POLITICS AT THE DOOR.

I also want to make a point that speaks to my general brilliance. I have not seen CHE and I have not seen a single scene of it, but everytime I imagine what the movie is going to be like in my head, I picture Del Toro in grain-vision and shaky camera walking through some burned-out war zone in REAL TIME with some ratting timpany music on the soundtrack, shot in the style of the Be Black Baby segments of DePalma's HI, MOM. That's TOTALLY what this movie should look like for four hours, AND it should have a scene of James Brolin in a military uniform, like in Traffic.

Is there canny timpani music and a FULL METAL JACKET like tracking scene?

How does one become a director? I live in Hollywood but I don't know anybody.

Posted by: LexG [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 01:13 AM

You become a director the same way anybody else does. Get some initiative, get up off your arse and do something for yourself.

Dave, has it been confirmed that Che will be released in it's entirety or what? Didn't I read they're releasing it as Che for an awards run, but then seperately otherwise...? Or am I making that up.

I can easily see it being split in some territories and kept as a whole in others.

Posted by: KamikazeCamelV2.0 [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 02:05 AM

I so wish I could see this in one viewing! But in Spain we'll get it in 2 parts. In fact "The Argentine" is already out, am trying to find time to go see it.

Dave, a question: is the original version in English or Spanish? I'd heard rumours it was in Spanish... which would mean that for once I won't be seeing a dubbed film, yay!

Posted by: crazycris [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 02:08 AM

Great review, I definitely won't be missing this.

Posted by: movielocke [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 03:42 AM

Wow.

Not to diminish what is a great review but...

Poland and Wells. In total agreement for once. Two voices holding out against the rest of the critical world.

I imagine them as the on-line Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.

"Next time I say let's go to Cuba, let's GO to Cuba!"

Posted by: jackfly11 [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 06:23 AM

Crazycris, there is very limited use of English in the movie, so I would guess you'll just have to suffer with some English subtitles getting in your way. I was at the same screening as DP, and I enjoyed the movie fine, but it really does remove any "negative" aspects of Che and the revolution and put it onto other people (whether that is true or not). It is definitely not a balanced movie, but it is not trying to be. Benico's performance is absolutely amazing.

Posted by: Kambei [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 06:26 AM

Great review, DP. Looking forward to seeing this.

Now, where's that "Death Race" review?!?! (j/k - though I fucking loved "Death Race")

Posted by: SJRubinstein [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 06:40 AM

From Anne Thompson's blog:

"IFC will open the full four-hour movie with an intermission for one-week Oscar-qualifying runs in New York and Los Angeles before opening Che Part One (The Argentine) in 15 to 25 key markets in January; Part Two (The Guerilla) will follow the Oscar nominations announcement. The two movies will be made available on video-on-demand concurrent with their wider theatrical runs."

Posted by: djk813 [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 09:42 AM

I expect that IFC's plans are fluid, depending on what kind of response they see.

In my opinion, splitting them up is suidical on IFC's part. The majority of people who will rush to see this film will either be very interested because of their relationship to the material or will be cinema lovers who are excited by the idea of a one-of-a-kind 4.5 hour movie experience.

Besides... one half doesn't really work without the other half... it really IS one movie.

Yes, most of the film is in Spanish.

And as for the politics, the film may be too kind or not kind enough to Che'... but that's not really the point of the film... nor is the embrace of communism as any kind of panacea. They found the universal in the specific and the point is there, not in the politics.

And thanks, Jackfly... in spite of Jeff's years of trying to equate what we do, we really aren't in the same business. Perhaps he can ride with Roger Friedman and Nikki Finke.... the 3 Unmigos.

Posted by: David Poland [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 17, 2008 10:47 AM

What, did Nicol take the day off?

I'd have lost that wager.

Posted by: LexG [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 18, 2008 12:43 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?